iPad 2 = WINNING. iOS 4.3 = NOT winning.
March 3, 2011 1 Comment
Let me get one thing across: the iPad 2 is a marvelous piece of hardware. Just when you didn’t think the iPad couldn’t get any slimmer and pack two cameras, it still can. The iPad 2 will succeed just like its predecessor, and that’s fine by me because it deserves it on the hardware end for the most part. I’m not going to describe the specs; you can check them out at apple.com/ipad . I also LOVE the smart covers…ingenious.
I am also glad that Steve Jobs came back to announce the new iPad; it shows that he is still very much alive and in control of the company he loves.
However, some things bothered me about the keynote (besides my main point coming up):
- Yes, the iPad 2 is the thinnest and lightest tablet out on the market probably…but other than that, there’s not much to it. The camera specs are vague at best; we just know that that the FaceTime (front) camera is VGA quality. The Motorola XOOM, on the other hand, uses a 2MP front-facing camera and a 5MP back camera. We do not know the current specifications of the back camera for the iPad 2, although I want to take a stab and guess it’ll also be a VGA camera or 3 MP, at best, because it seems very similar to the iPod Touch camera.
- It also bothers me that Steve Jobs kept on harping the iPad as not just some minor tweaking. OK, sure, it has an A5 processor, can do 1080p output, etc. But I feel like all of that still could have merited without an event like this. If there was discussion about MobileMe or even just cloud services in general, this would have been different. But iPad 2 plus a bunch of apps? I guess it kinda works, but it was still head-scratching at the end.
- It kind of relates to a report MacRumors had gotten last night about an “Apple staffer” saying that this update wasn’t exactly worth it. , but I have a feeling Steve Jobs felt like he NEEDED to be there to save the iPad. I hate to speculate, especially with his health being involved, but I feel like he felt he needed to be there because he knew that his temporary return would capture most of the attention compared to mostly under-the-hood changes to the iPad 2. Again, I’m not gonna go far out in saying that he was using his health condition to his advantage necessarily, but I feel like he knew that if he was up on stage it’d be better than if Tim Cook was on stage.
The main point that bothered me, however, was the lack of updates for iOS…and not even a single mention of MobileMe. Everyone who has an iPhone knows how stupid iOS’s notification system is…you’re texting along and all of a sudden you’re stopped by this annoying little bubble from one of your many apps that you really don’t want to see right at the moment. Android has a much less intrusive and much more informative/systematic notification system, but Apple decided to be “simplistic”. By doing so, however, they decided to be annoying.
I also have a problem with lack of widgets, or at least the icons not telling me any information but just how many things are waiting to tell me something. It’s the most useless use of space ever, it really is. Android does a good job of mixing information with portals/icons/apps. I can look at my homescreen for the current weather without having to prod through an app just to get to current weather conditions, and then prod through some more settings to see a 7-day, for instance. On a tablet, this is even more pronounced with the expanded real-estate. Honeycomb isn’t a perfect OS, but it’s an ideal OS. It can be made as simplistic or as complicated as one would like…Google + carrier companies need to do a better job of guiding the end-user in simplifying or expanding the user experience. But Honeycomb has infinite possibilities…iOS, in its current state, does not.
Which made me realize something: I’m not an Apple Fanboy…I’m a Mac Fanboy. I love the operating system because I can be as simplistic or as complicated as I want to be. Windows, admittedly, allows more extensivity but the aesthetics of Mac OS X can be made as simple or as complicated as can be; just look at my menubar. It’s a one stop shop where I can see everything that I need to see without making a single keyboard shortcut or mouse click.
(click on image to expand: I can check the weather, how much RAM my computer is using, and even check iCal events just by looking up).
Instead of trying to port iOS stuff to OS X, Apple needs to consider porting some stuff from OS X to iOS again. I’m not saying we need an omnipresent menu bar in iOS, obviously, but we need some sort of innovative system for pulling up the information we would like to know most in an unobtrusive manner. For crying out loud, Growl notifications were pioneered on OS X and yet now they’re showing up very nicely in Honeycomb? Apple’s slowly but steadily losing its mobile software grip, and they need to find a way to recover fast.
I’ve already decided…unless the allure of the iPad 2 really gets to me (or the cheapness of the first generation iPad), to make a pact with a friend of mine that if the Motorola XOOM wi-fi version is less than $600 that we’re going to buy our own XOOMs. The iPad 2, physically, is really nice. But hardware can only do so much…software picks everything else up. And at this point, iOS 4.3 doesn’t do it anymore. It has some great improvements…just not the best improvements. And now, since it looks like we won’t even get to have a developer preview of iOS 5 until July, it looks like we’ll be doing a lot more waiting.


